In MLB The Show 26, the new Untouchable designation in Franchise Mode is a game-changer. It lets you lock down your most valuable players so the AI doesn’t accidentally trade them or lowball offers. Using it smartly can make the difference between a long-term dynasty and a team that slowly falls apart.



Who Should Be Untouchable



When deciding who to protect, focus on three main groups:



1. Foundation Stars

These are your highest-rated players with long-term contracts. For example, Gunnar Henderson is often a must-keep early in the season. Marking them as Untouchable:



Prevents accidental trades.

Shows the AI that these players are off-limits.



2. Elite Prospects (Top 100)

Any prospect with A-tier potential should be locked immediately. In MLB 26, the AI automatically lists 5–20 players as untouchable by default, but you’ll want to check your Top 100 prospects to make sure none slip through. This protects your future stars.



3. Young, Salary-Controlled Talent

Players who are pre-arbitration but performing at an All-Star level are golden. Making them untouchable:



Keeps them developing cheaply.

Ensures they become long-term cornerstones.

Strategic Use of Untouchable Status



The trade system in 2026 has moved away from instant trades. The CPU now takes several days to evaluate deals, which adds complexity. Here’s how Untouchable status helps:



Prevent AI “Theft”

Other teams may try to block your trades or swoop in during the pending period. Protect your core to avoid losing key pieces.



Maintain Market Value

If you have multiple players at one position, don’t mark everyone untouchable. Only protect your starter so bench or prospect pieces still have trade value.



Rebuild vs. Contend



Rebuilding: Keep only A or B potential prospects untouchable. Older stars can be traded to accelerate your rebuild.

Contending: Protect all your core stars and elite prospects to maintain a competitive roster.

Suggested Untouchable Categories

Player Category Priority Reason

Elite Star (90+ OVR) High Core of the roster; prevents AI lowball offers

A-Potential Prospect High Essential for long-term dynasty growth

Gold Glove Defenders Medium Defense scales well over long seasons

High H/9 & K/9 Pitchers Medium Elite pitching is harder to replace than hitting

Quick Tips

Regularly review your untouchable list at the start of each season.

Don’t mark everyone; selective protection keeps trades flexible.

Remember: untouchable is dynamic. Players can move in or out of this status based on performance, potential, and age.



By carefully managing your Untouchable list, you’ll safeguard your franchise’s future while maximizing trade value and keeping your winning core intact. In MLB The Show 26, knowing who to protect is as important as knowing how to win on the field.